Cookie Butter Ice Cream - 1.5qt - Favorite Day™
$4.99 ($0.10/fluid ounce)
In Stock
Eligible for registries and wish lists
About this item
Additional product information and recommendations
Related Categories
Frequently bought together
3.9 out of 5 stars with 54 reviews
quality: 3.86 out of 5
taste: 3.59 out of 5
value: 3.5 out of 5
61% would recommend
21 recommendations
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
18 February, 2026Verified purchase
Bestest cookie butter ice cream!
Delicious ice cream. This is our favorite cookie butter ice cream of all the brands we’ve tried. And we’ve tried several.!! please don’t discontinue this
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
22 January, 2026Verified purchase
All time favorite ice cream
Amazing! I wish this wasn’t seasonal.
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
22 December, 2025Verified purchase
Favorite day does it every time
10/10 delicious omg. It tastes exactly like a snickerdoodle cookie, less like cookie butter. Flavor is spot on so good. Favorite day ice cream especially seasonal flavors are just top tier!!
3 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
22 December, 2025Verified purchase
deceptive
I really thought I was getting ice cream with cookie butter in it or that was cookie butter flavored because it's marketed as "cookie butter ice cream". But there is no cookie butter in it nor does it taste like cookie butter. It just tastes like cinnamon with graham cracker pieces. It's good but not that good. I wouldn't buy again. And I feel decieved over the lies on the carton.
4 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
21 December, 2025Verified purchase
Holiday ice cream!
Surprisingly better than I thought it would be! Stronger cinnamon taste than I’d prefer, but great holiday option for something different! Even the kiddos enjoyed it. The cookie swirls are delicious and it’s a decent price for what you get.
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
21 December, 2025Verified purchase
OMG OBSESSED
I almost ate an entire carton in one sitting. Need I say more?! Very very sweet ice cream part, and there's a cinnamon and ginger bread sort of swirl that is HEAVENLY. if you love anything cinnamon you will love this! I hope this helps anyone who doesn't know what cookie butter is because I had never had cookie butter before so I didn't know what I was getting into 😁
4 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
16 December, 2025Verified purchase
Not cookie butter, but delicious!
It’s more of a churro ice cream. It’s super yummy!
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
13 December, 2025Verified purchase
Under rated
Tastes just like described. Maybe not the traditional cookie butter taste people might have expected but still really good.
4 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
10 December, 2025Verified purchase
(no review title)
Yummy but not cookie butter
2 out of 5 stars
9 December, 2025Verified purchase
(no review title)
If you’re fortunate to have a Trader Joe’s near you, get their cookie butter. Favorite Day just isn’t very good I am sorry to say.
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
8 December, 2025Verified purchase
Not worth it
There was absolutely zero graham cracker swirl. Definitely not cookie butter. I would say cinnamon cookie maybe.
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
6 December, 2025Verified purchase
No Cookie Butter
No Cookie Butter. It's just cinnamon ice cream and graham crackers pieces, thats not cookie butter !
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
1 December, 2025Verified purchase
Amazing! Just not Cookie Butter. Please Bring it Back Next Year!
This is not cookie butter flavor (just a trendy flavor they were marketing to for a quick buck). However, if you take the time to read the flavor description you can see that. This tastes almost exactly like my favorite B&J pint (Oat of this World). I really hope they continue to bring this one back. Maybe name it different though.
1 out of 5 stars
29 November, 2025
Not as expected
This flavor should not be called cookie butter. It should be called cinnamon graham cracker. There is no hint of cookie butter. Quite a bit of cinnamon though.
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
23 November, 2025Verified purchase
Artificial cinnamon
Don’t get it if you don’t like the FAKE artificial cinnamon taste. The aftertaste throws off the ice cream all together.
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
22 November, 2025Verified purchase
Excellent
Unbelievable
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
22 November, 2025
misleading
more gingerbread marshmallow like than anything cookie butter.
1 out of 5 stars
22 November, 2025Verified purchase
(no review title)
It tastes like gingerbread spice play dough. No cookie butter flavor at all.
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
21 November, 2025
Misleading flavor name
It doesn’t taste anything like cookie butter. It’s got way too much cinnamon, and lacks the depth that biscoff has. The texture isn’t as nice as other Favorite Day ice creams.
2 out of 5 stars
20 November, 2025Verified purchase
(no review title)
Just meh. Wouldn’t buy again