KVD Beauty Paraben Free Aluminum Tattoo Eyeliner - Ulta Beauty

It‘s not as good as I imagined; it still smudges.

Order 2 Mad Max Brown eyeliners, received 2 Mad Max Brown eyeliners but one of them is actually in Black even the eyeliner says Mad Max Brown.

I used to get KVD eyeliner for years, switched to WetnWild breakup proof liner because of the pricepoint, and now I'm back because i'd rather treat myself! THIS STUFF IS GREAT FOR PRECISION. I will ALWAYS opt for a brush tip over a felt tip because of this! The minis WILL dry up faster than the regular size. Just be sure to shake them up before using, and if you need to- test it on your hand first to make sure the product is flowing!

If they changed this formula, I missed it. It's weirdly shiny when I put it on now, not looking as black as it used to. And it's sticky??? I've never had a sticky pen before. Compared it to my old one I have a few drops of left and my new pen is sticky, I have to power it down a little or use a fan to dry it before I open my hooded eyes or it sticks to my eyelid and sometimes leaves an imprint. Used to be my go-to eyeliner for years but I might switch now. Otherwise, the brush is still nice and precise. I only have an issue with the current formula.

I have been wearing this liner probably for 5+ years and loved it. I have hooded eyes and it was the only liner that wouldn't transfer to my eyelid. I bought a replacement and could tell right away something was different. My eyes felt goopy when I would blink and it was all over my eyelids. It is so unfortunate… just be aware that the quality is not where it used to be. It's a mess

So easy to use. This liner is perfect flows smoothly . Isn't too wet that it makes a mess but goes on so well when applying. I've tried a lot of different liquid liner and this is definitely THE BEST

I've tried to like this a few times, I even went out on a limb for my vacation and bought the travel size. This stuff dries out a few days after opening it. I would not recommend this product at all!!

I was so excited to try this eyeliner. I read a bunch of reviews and what completely stood out was how waterproof it claimed to be. Well, it’s not. I’ve used it daily for a week now and every day, it wipes off and smears on my lids. Every single day. There’s an elf eyeliner at a fraction of the price that doesn’t do this. So sad.

My favorite liner of all time. It is dark and stays on

This used to be my holy grail. Ive purchased this for yeaaaarrrssss. At some point in the last few years they changed the formula and its terrible. Its patchy, dries out quick. It isnt even the blackest eye liner on the market anymore. Its a shame what they did to this product.

The cover kept popping off and it dried out within a week.

I used to use this back in the day bedoenrhe brand got bought out. Its terrible. No pigment whaysoever. Dried out upon buying. Do not waste your money.

This is by far the BEST eyeliner I've ever used. I usually have a terrible time with liquid liners bleeding which makes it difficult to get a clean line. This goes on so smoothly, lasts all day, and allows me to get the look I want; even with my hooded eyes! I will never buy another brand!

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] Takes a bit to dry, so it smudges easily. After it is dried it looks great and crisp and clean lines. Washes off easily with oil based face cleanser.

I have been using this eyeliner for nearly ten years but after they changed the formula its terrible. I have hooded eyes and this used to be the holy grail of eyeliners but now it smudges everywhere no matter what I do and its just so sticky. I feel like my eyelids are constantly sticking to my crease and every time I glance in the mirror I have smudges nearly to my brows. So so disappointed. Still need to find a dupe.

The BEST eyeliner I have ever used. I have tried sooo many different eyeliner brands. This is by far the best eyeliner.

This used to be the holy grail but man the way they messed with the formula has killed it. Tranfers to the eyelid after an hour of wear. Dissapointing.

I just bought this because I used to use it years ago and loved it! I’ve spent 20 minutes shaking it and it’s not even opaque!! Such a waste of money😤😤

They rolled out a new formula and it's absolutely awful. Why they would change a formula that has been a holy grail formula for over a decade is a mystery. Save your money, do not buy the new version of this liner.

I like it because the size is handy to keep in my purse for touch ups.