tarte Maneater Waterproof Mascara - Black - 0.3 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

I needed a nice waterproof option as everything else I used would fall onto my bottom eyelid. I like how it thinly coats my lashes and I can choose how much to build/thicken it up.

I really wanted to love this mascara … but I could not. The mascara smudges… in under 2 hours! And it definitely flakes as time goes on. The length and volume achieved are nice … but who wants to keep cleaning up under your eyes? Not me …

Mascara held up great when I needed a total eye flushing at work when sedation drugs accidentally squirted into my eye. Still looked great after the whole ordeal

LOVE this mascara. 10/10 recommend. As a women with very watery eyes, this is the only mascara I have found that last all day, Doesn't run, is affordable and great quality.

The brush is the best one I have found, unfortunately it is not waterproof at all!!

Mascara goes on nice enough but was definitely not waterproof . Purchased for a trip and it was very disappointing would return but I threw box away!

Not waterproof AT ALL, it flakes off like crazy, and smears. It's so far from waterproof it's actually laughable.

No idea if this is waterproof, but it certainly isnt smudge-proof, as I had black panda eyes 3-4 hours after applyng. Very disappointed, so I have stopped using it. Awful product.

The one star is purely for the fact that this waterproof mascara in NOT at all waterproof. Everything else about it is great. Thankfully I only bought the travel size to take on vacation.

I like how big it is, but it isn't waterproof.. I have sensitive eyes where they always water from allergies thinking this would be the best solution and it wasn't and way too expensive

Love it

I am not sure that I would purchase this product again. Packaging is good, color is accurate, brush is full and fluffy however, I didn't find this to be waterproof. A little warm water and soap makes this mascara run and bleed enough to smudge under my eyes. I think I'll go back to my og pick.

I am in search of a mascara that doesn't rub off under my eye. The clerk told me that this one will work. Nope, ended up under my eye by noon after applying before work. I powder under my eyes and other "tricks" to prevent it, but my search will continue. Bummed that this little travel size cost more than other brands that held up longer.

Its good mascara but 100% not waterproof at all. Thank god i bought the travel size and not the full size

There is something about this mascara that keeps me coming back time and time again. No, it is not water proof. Yes, it does smudge overtime. But the brush, the formula, its just different. The brush separtes my lashes so well since theres so many bristles, it never gets clumpy or goopy. I can apply two coats and its enough to get my lashes to reach the ceiling. Ive gotten so many compliments on it and have recommended it many people, giving it similar praises as my own. Its not the perfect mascara, but its my favorite and i will always repurchase it. This is near my 12th tube at this point.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] the applicator brush is the best I have ever used. There is no clumping or smearing of the mascara. I will be buying this and telling my friends about this mascara.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Love this mascara. It works great and doesn’t smear.

This is the only mascara that does not make my eyes burn with contacts in. I can sweat, I can rub my eyes and it stays put for 10+ hours.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I had been using Tartelette XL, which I loved. But I started having trouble with watery eyes, and it made a goopy mess. I decided to try this since it is waterproof. When my eyes water it doesn’t make as much of a mess as the Tartelette, but some of it still comes off. Aside from that issue, it does a nice job of adding volume and length. I still like Tartelette XL better, but I’ll stick with this until I get my watery eye issues sorted out.

I have been wearing it every since a girlfriend gifted me a couple years ago🤩