Too Faced Killer Liner 36 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner - 0.04oz - Ulta Beauty

Whole i absolutely love the liner, wears well and all... the sharpening is infuriating!! You either have to sharpen WAY too far and waste a ton of very expensive product or it leaves insanely sharp points that hurt if they touch your lids!! There really had to be a better design for such a pricey product!!

I used to love this eyeliner, the last 2 times I've purchased, its breaking off, wasting a ton of product. I asked Ulta if i could exchange it, they told me to just push the liner back into the pencil. Ummm, no thank you! Will not purchase again and am not happy with Ulta either.

Barely lasts an hr, difficult to remove totally disappointed

The color goes on easily and even on the water line, but the product runs out fast! I've used it for less than two weeks, and it's almost out. I just tried to sharpen it, and I ruined the tip. Not worth the money at all.

Best eyeliner I have ever used. No melting and running odd my face. Lol

Love this eye liner but it get's smaller and smaller. I bought a new one opened it and the tip fell off. The tip was the entire eye liner. Such a rip off. On a journey to find another eyeliner.

This is my lip pencil and it is the perfect chocolate color for that brown nude shade.

This works way better than UD for me. Storm is my favorite color. Idk why it has so many bad reviews. This is great when you know how to use it :)

Goes on great, love the color but sometimes at the end of the day it seems smudged

Def buy again and again!

I usually use Urban Decay waterproof eyeliner but tried this Too Faced one because it was on sale. I love colors and Urban Decay met that need; however, some of the colors wouldn't stay put. I am a very "hot" person and makeup needs to be super waterproof for me. Anyway, this one from Too Faced stayed on for 4 days of showering, sleeping, washing my face 2x a day and gardening! I didn't rub my eyes or use makeup remover. I just wanted to see how long it would look "nice". By the 4th day, the brown was just at the corners but it wasn't in my pillow case or under my eyes. I am going to try another color or two before I make the switch, but the glittery brown is just what I need for now. I should mention, the gel goes on clean and smooth, no tugging or long drying time. This is important to my aging skin.

Once the pencil becomes dull (after the 3rd time using it) -- there's no way to sharpen it. I tried with different sharpeners, but since the pencil is plastic, it breaks the tip and you end up with a sharp plastic end! Save your money!

Great eyeliner smooth coverage

This eyeliner is amazing besides the plastic is hard to sharpen. OK OK BUT...... If you get Urben Decay makeup sharpener it WORKS AMAZING! I bought at least 10 sharpeners but this one does the job, so buy them together! YOUR WELCOME ❤️

i've been looking for an eyeliner that is smudge proof and long lasting and i thought this was the one. i tested it on my hand and let it sit a little, and it didn't move when i touched it ! it was even a little difficult to remove with makeup wipes, so i purchased it bc that's something i wanted in an eyeliner. i tried it the next day and i noticed, it was smudging onto my bottom lash line. everytime i would clean up my eyes, it would still smudge and transfer to my bottom lashes. sharpening it is also a pain, idk if it's just my sharpener but it kept breaking and i couldn't get a good tip to use. i do not recommend this product if you have oily skin bc it does not last and smudges alottttt !!

This is the only eyeliner that stays on my waterline. My issue is with the value, once the pencil gets below half used, it's impossible to sharpen. I can't a tip at all & I've even had the remaining stick inside fall out. 2F PLEASE fix this!

I've tried so many eyeliners. I use on my waterline only, so, hard to find one that actually stays. I used to use the Marc Jacobs, but when they went out of business, it took me a long time to find a replacement. This is it. It's perfect, does the job and beautiful color brown to match my eyes. Love this product, I was shocked when I saw it only has 3 stars. If I could give it a 100, I would.

Easy to use and long lasting. Does not smudge and looks great all day.

I did not realize this was not an automatic pencil, it is made out of plastic, so it's very difficult to sharpen and for the price you need to be able to use it the whole pencil! I gave it two stars because the formula is good and its long lasting.

The color is right on for what I needed it for. However, the quality is below what I would consider "good" considering the price tag. I did need to heat it up a bit to make it work the way I needed to. However, it is a solid choice if you are going for a more subtle look than I was.