Under Eye Balm with Caffeine - 0.5 fl oz - Goodfellow & Co™: Dark Circle Reduction, Paraben-Free, Contains Hyaluronic Acid

I ordered this product online. I've been using it off and on over a few months now and I've never noticed any different between when I use the product and when I don't, not any long-term difference. More significantly, when I first received the product, the bottle had cracked at the neck and spilled all over everything in the box I ordered. Target was quick to ship me a new one which I haven't had issue with until now. The last time I used it, I noticed an identical crack in the neck of the bottle had developed. It seems to me there is a design flaw in this bottle or the plastic is so cheap that the simple screwing on off the cap is liable to form a crack all the way through the bottle. Since you can only get the product out by squeezing the bottle, this crack in the neck renders it useless. Squeezing the bottle will force a large amount of the product out of the bottle through the crack and it is extremely difficult to control the flow. This leads to a huge amount of waste if I want to use the product and leads to me over applying the product leaving my skin feeling sticky under my eyes. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone.

I like this product because I really do feel like it helps with any puffiness or circles underneath my eyes. However, the packaging has changed over the year or two and now instead of a roller ball we’re left with a plastic tip that consistently cracks or breaks, letting the balm leak out between uses.

Although this product seemed nice and smooth, it was too runny for me.

Very watery, not a balm it's a kind of lotion. I was hoping for a balm. Should have returned it

This was a lot lighter and thinner then I expected. Also there is nothing on the tip that you had to pull off. I don't like when beauty products don't have some sort of tamper proof packaging. The packaging is sleek it's geared towards men but I'm a woman and I tried it. I think I need to use it a few more times to see if I see any results. I only did one under eye so far because I wanted to make sure there was no reaction. So far it's been fine no reaction the product was cool to the touch.

The Goodfellow & Co. Caffeine Eye Balm is a great budget-friendly option for refreshing and depuffing the under-eye area. It has a nice cooling, slightly tingly sensation that feels especially good in the morning! It is also lightweight, absorbs quickly, and doesn’t leave a greasy or sticky residue. For dark circles it’s definitely temporary but maybe with long term use it will help more.

This is coffee for your eyes!! This is magic in a bottle, I use this every morning and it makes it look like I got a good night sleep! No more dark circles or bags under my eyes with this Goodfellow eye balm. I dab a little under my eyes after washing my face and follow up with my foundation, It goes on smooth and soaks into my skin nicely. It doesn’t dry out or make my skin irritated, the skin under my eyes feel hydrated and smooth.

This is a product I desperately needed. The packaging is easy to use and control the amount I use which is nice. It feels cool upon application and I saw a noticeable difference right away. I would recommend this product and I plan to continue using it.

Great product! Love the way it makes my skin feels. Really helps with the puffiness and dark circles. Does not irritate the eyes and smells great. Goes on silky and smooth with no residue. Love that it contains caffeine. I recommend this product to everyone.

This feels pretty nice when you put it on. It is nourishing and made my under eyes look a little better. I had no irritation which is rare for me. So I think it’s a pretty decent product. I will use this daily.

I can't say that it 100% works as I've only used it for a couple days. It does seem to help lighten under the eye a little 10 minutes after putting it on. But I can also say that if you have sensitive skin to be careful of using this. I've used a couple different types of under eye creams and this was the only one that burned me after putting it on. Once I rubbed it off and cleaned my skin the burning was gone, so something in this brand was bothersome to me.

A perfect pick-me-up for tired days. This caffeine eye balm is soothing with a clean, non sticky finish. The balm texture is watery and hydrating. The caffeine also provides a cooling effect with a subtle coffee scent. All these things combined really helps with my tired eyes and helps me feel refreshed the next morning. I love it!

The cream is light and smooth. It is easy to apply and makes your face start to feel brighter and lighter in minutes. Reduces puffiness as well just as advertised. Makes it easy to feel good about yourself and the way you look.

This eye cream is hydrating and easy to apply. It is a little thin though, and I prefer a thicker eye cream. This would be a good every day eye cream for people with minimal wrinkles under their eyes to maintain good skin.