This is the worst eyeliner I have ever used. Lined upper eyelids only. Used mascara afterwards and just having the mascara wand brush against lined part of lid lifted huge chunks of liner right off of my eyelid.
1 reply from Customer Care team - 8 days ago
We're extremely sorry to hear this eyeliner didn't perform how you expected, and we really want to make this right. Please call us at 1-800-582-4048 between 9 AM & 5:30 PM ET, M-F, so we can gather more information. Looking forward to hearing from you!
My first time using this product the brush would not get completely saturated and I could not get it to come out easily. If it did come out on the brush after vigorous shaking the lines were still not super straight because the tip of the brush doesn't hold the product well and was frayed. The product did last long and does not smudge once dry.
1 reply from Neutrogena team - 1 month ago
Hey there, thanks for the review! We're sorry that you had a negative experience with our eyeliner, we'd love to learn more. If you wouldn't mind giving us a call at 1-800-582-4048 M-F 9AM-5:30PM ET. When you call please mention your reviewer name to our specialist. Hope to chat soon!
Love the application ease of it, but need to layer it to get the "jet black." Love that it stays on all day, doesn't flake or rub off, which in a way makes it a bit more difficult to remove in the shower. Actual make up remover is necessary.
I have been looking for anew eyelinerin liquid form that doesn't make a huge mess when trying to apply incorrect. Finally found one. Might be a little on the pricey side for mebutNeutrogena is a great company and I have decided its worth the extra money I had to spend. Precision and no mess.
Fantastic find! One of the best drugstore brand liquid eyeliners out there! Color is true black. Very easy application, brush tip is just the right length to create a variety of looks. No flaking. Dries rather quickly, so it's pretty much smudge-proof. No flaking either. Lasts a long time. If needed, it's very easy to remove as well.
This eyeliner goes on so smooth and did not smudge at all. I purchased to use on my waterline. Unfortunately, it sting a little bit. I wish it didn't because I had been looking for an eyeliner that doesn't smudge. Also, I loved the size of the tip.