Pixi by Petra Endless Silky Waterproof Pen Eyeliner - 0.04oz

Sucks at sharpening. Tip did not nicely sharpen with a typical sharpener, as it stated. Color was nice and performed as i wanted. Doubtful ill get my moneys worth since the pencil is practically broken as it wont sharpen nicely.

I really wish this eyeliner would last longer than 3 business days. In all seriousness, for the price, you do not get much product. Also, what’s the point of the twisty green piece at the tip if twisting it doesn’t push up product? Makes no sense.

Let me start by saying that I’ve been a huge Pixi fan for years. I’ve bought so many of these eyeliners that black eyeliner has become a part of my identity. However, my eyes started stinging after I opened a new box of eyeliner a few months ago. I also noticed that my eyeliner wasn’t staying on as long as it used to… but I never had an issue with this product before (in probably close to 10 years) that ignored all the signs. I started the elimination test to figure out why my eyes were stinging - I stopped using my SPF, stopped using my moisturizer, stopped using my eye shadow and stopped using my eye primer. Unfortunately, my eyes were still stinging so I stopped using this eyeliner… and the stinging went away. Like I said, I’d been using this product for so long that I was in disbelief… so I started investigating a bit more and noticed that the packaging had changed from “waterproof” to “water resistant,” which made me suspect the formulation had also changed. It breaks my heart that I can’t use this eyeliner anymore between the stinging and the decrease in lasting power. (I also noticed that it got a bit flaky on my eyelids?) I hope that Pixi changes the formulation back so it’s back to the previous quality.

I wanted to love this but pencil is very hard on the eye lid

Great color, smooth application

Way too soft. Color wasn’t great either.. disappointing!

I had really high hopes as I was told it wouldn't smudge. Unfortunately with in a very short period, it was on my top eye lid, and the bottom created raccoon eyes.

Goes on soft but does not smear or transfer to top lid. Good dark blue.

Even in the 110+ degree heat (with accompanying sweat), this eyeliner stayed put all day, didn't run, and didn't flake. Yes, it wore off a bit in the creases (where I rub my eyes a bit) but that's it.

Beautiful color. Not waterproof... smudges horribly and transfers to/ruins contacts.

I have blond hair, light skin complection, green eyes. Any black or dark eyeliner looks too harsh on my face. I really like this eyeliner in London Fog shade. It's pefect for me. I like how easy this eyeliner can be applied. It's not super lasting for the whole day, but still looks good a bit smadged after some time. I wish this particular shade doesn't get discontinued.

It's the only one I have used for many years now.

Bought for my mom and she too is unable to twist to sharpen. Very disappointing because she really likes color and easy to go on but useless if can’t sharpen and was only able to use once!!!

I got the bronze beam…. Love it. It’s hard to find a brown eyeliner that isn’t basically black or super gold. Perfect brown!

Using it fresh out of the box was amazing. It stayed on until I washed it off. But sharpening it is a nightmare. It just breaks off in chunks, which is so sad because I loved how it looked. Guess I have to return unfortunately. Was so excited to find a lavender color.

I don’t usually buy drugstore makeup and I’m glad I took a chance on this. Goes on super smooth, stays on well, nice pigment, and doesn’t irritate my super sensitive eyes. I looked at their website which advised sticking the pencil in the freezer before sharpening and that worked like a charm - I’m going to start doing that with other pencils too. I purchased the bronze color.

I was so excited to use these, so I purchased 2- the plum color and the bronzed color. I used these on my eyelids and near the water line (because the packaging says it's water proof) Immediately, my eyes begin to water. Also, it seems the formula is so soft, it's going to need sharping soon. I'm going to return soon.

I have been having terrible issues with my contacts for the last couple of days and couldn’t figure out why since I rarely do. Just realized I bought a new kind of eyeliner. When I looked up the reviews, one of the comments is about how they damage contacts! I’m done!!

I purchased this as a gift for someone with EXTRA sensitive skin; they had been using a stila one that apparently was discontinued. She needs the liner to be creamy but not turn her eye into an allery war zone. This did that and now it's all she uses

Had a reaction to it, first time with any product. Made my lids puff and itch. Also clumpy formula, required blending.