19oz Tall Recycled Pint Glass Brown - Hearth & Hand™ with Magnolia

I’m giving one star because I have to not because I want to . Please don’t buy the tumblers they are not colored glass it is a plastic film that wears off and looks so horrible after a few washes. I don’t have a dishwasher all my dishes are washed by hand and I am so upset if I would have known they had a film I would have never purchased these drinking cups!

I bought 6 in the golden color, I thought they were really nice. At that time they were priced at $9 or $9.99 a glass, which I thought was high, so I found the scanner on the post and the price was just that. This was the only color that they had in stock at the time. Then about a month later I went in and found the brown color tumblers and the price was $5.99 for them and I got 6 more. In about 3 months, they all started to crackle, peel and get milky on the finish. The peeled bits would get on all the cleaned dishes and filter of my dishwasher. All of my new glasses are pretty much trashed now. They have never been used in a microwave. They have only been handwashed or washed in the dishwasher on the top shelf. On the lable it does not say DO NOT WASH IN THE DISHWASHER. I have only had them since November or December. I'm now into them for $100 or more with tax for 12 glasses. HORRIBLE PRODUCT!! I'm very surprised and dissapointed that "Hearth & Hand by Magnolia has put their name these glasses. If I could give them zero stars, I would!

the price tag stripped off the glass coating

These were great for one second….until i washed them. These are NOT dishwasher NOR hot water (hand washing) safe. Whatever cheap garbage they used to get the “amber glass” look is a cheap plastic-y disaster that peels + flakes off and cannot be safe. 🥴 So, if you like your drinks spiked with chunks of brown chemically flakes - these were made for you babe! If not - avoid at all costs.

Brown film coating glass chips off even having only been hand washed

Wanted to love these but they peel. So aggravating!!!!!!!

very cute but after a few washes the film on the glass peels off.

ZERO STARS. We purchased these cups, in all colors and sizes, to refresh our kitchen. After just a couple uses and washes --- all the cups are peeling. Horrible product from H&H.

No No No! The brown film peels off after washing. Do not waste any money.

Didn’t even use them once just took off the price sticker off the bottom and the color came off so they went back to the store

They are beautiful, a good size, and the smoky brown color is gorgeous.

They peel unfortunately

These glasses peel

I loved these glasses so much. They were the perfect color, felt heavy and were just the style I was looking for. It’s hard to find amber glasses! I was so very disappointed to find that the amber color was pealing off after two uses! These glasses are painted out glazed amber, they are not truly amber! The quality was very shocking for Hearth and Hand.

Trash cups

Like many others i’ve had four of these glasses for less than a year and they’re all peeling. Three are almos completely peeled away from our dishwasher.

Used them once and they started peeling. I do not have a dishwasher, but I use warm water on my dishes. I think this is why they started peeling. I wish I would have let the reviews before purchasing very disappointed with the quality of this product as these glasses are expensive.

I bought 8 of these but in the Yellow Tint on 7/12/25, they were $9.99 each... so NOT cheap glasses in comparisons to others at Target. I spent about 90 bucks on the glasses with taxes. These has a tag that says they are not dishwasher safe and to hand wash which is a pain, but we complied to keep them nice. After 2-3 uses they began to peel. This is not colored glass like the price would suggest. It is clear glass with with an exterior coating in varrious different colors. The coating doesn't even hold up to handwashing with dawn dish soap and a soft sponge. I can't believe Joanna Gaines lets these be assocciated with her and her brands. One of the worst products I've purchased. I dropped an ice cube in one and the bottom of the glass didn't break but rather just seperated from the cylinder part of the glass in 2 perfect pieces like it was glued togeather. I was so mad and Target wouldn't accept them as a return even though I had the reciept and was within the 365 day return policy and clearly it was a product defect. I brought them home and determined to not waste all my money I soaked them in 91% isopropyl rubbing alcohol for 30 minutes on each side of the glass and the coating came right off for the most part with steel wool and a light buff. After that I rinsed, sprayed with dawn power wash and let them sit and then scrubbed with a sponge and barkeepers friend to get off the rest and then rinsed and put them through a pots and pans high heat cycle in the dishwasher to remove any additional residue. So now they are clear and at least I can use them without going out and getting another new set. I'd be currious to know what they heck is in that film though since we certainly were drinking little bits of it before we realized they were peeling in the first place. DO NOT BUY THESE! I wouldn't reccomend purchasing them if they were at the Dollar Tree for a buck!

This is certainly not dishwasher safe. All the brown coloring has chipped off

The website listing says you can put them in the dishwasher, the sticker on the cups says hand wash only. Also when I was taking the stickers off of the bottom, just washing them and soaking in dawn scrubbed off the color on the base of the cup.