Natural No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter - 40oz - Good & Gather™
Only at target
$3.99 ($0.10/ounce)
In Stock
Eligible for registries and wish lists
About this item
Additional product information and recommendations
Discover more options
Frequently bought together
Guests also viewed
Related Categories
Guests are saying
This peanut butter has received mixed feedback from guests, with many expressing disappointment over its texture and taste. While some appreciate its affordability and creamy consistency, others find it too thick, dry, and lacking the authentic peanut flavor. The presence of palm oil and sugar has also raised concerns among health-conscious guests. Overall, it may serve well for cooking or smoothies, but many guests suggest exploring other brands for a more satisfying experience.
Summary created by AI from text of reviews reflecting recent feedback provided across different star ratings (includes incentivized reviews)
4.1 out of 5 stars with 590 reviews
quality: 2.83 out of 5
taste: 2.95 out of 5
value: 3.35 out of 5
34% would recommend
113 recommendations
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
13 May, 2026Verified purchase
What even is this?
I’ve never seen anything like this. “No stir” is an understatement. You couldn’t stir it if you wanted to. You have to basically cut it out of the jar, it’s so thick. I put peanut butter on a toasted English muffin for breakfast and I have to put a brick of this on immediately out of the toaster and hope that it melts it a little just to be able to somewhat spread it. Forget about putting it on bread for a pb&j. It just rips the bread. And it doesn’t really have much of a taste. It’s very strange. I’ve always used Skippy Natural but the ingredients were the same and for almost $2 cheaper I thought I’d give it a try. Just save yourself the hassle and stick with what you already use bc this peanut butter is just not good.
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
12 May, 2026Verified purchase
(no review title)
love this stuff it is not dry like other brands
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
1 May, 2026Verified purchase
Too dry.
Poor-quality ingredients and it was way too dry. I definitely wouldn’t buy it again.
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
30 April, 2026Verified purchase
Probably one of the worst PB I've tasted.
I bought this since I usually trust the good and gather brand but how do you mess up peanut butter? There is something super off and almost bitter/metallic about the taste. I wish I hadn't bought the bigger size because I'm going to have to deal with for a long time unless I want to break down and buy new peanut butter. Disappointing.
3 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
26 April, 2026Verified purchase
Its fine
It’s edible peanut butter. It’s nothing special. Most of my family thought it didn’t taste as good as regular peanut butter.
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
5 April, 2026
Way too dry, not going to buy again.
So so so dry and thick. Impossible to spread - tore up bread and flatbreads! Also if you get the 40oz jar you better be prepared to use a long heavy duty spatula to get the bottom half out - seriously next to impossible.
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
1 April, 2026Verified purchase
Gray paste?
a fan of target brands in general, but this... we bought bc it has the same ingredients as Skippy natural but was cheaper. I'm not sure how it's possible to mess up peanut butter, but it is super thick and dryish paste, grayish color. no peanut taste. I literally doubt the ingredients list is accurate, it's that bad. we threw it out. it even made horrible pb cookies.
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
29 March, 2026Verified purchase
favorite PB brand
affordable and favorite taste for peanut butter
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
25 March, 2026Verified purchase
(no review title)
The flavor was not good. It just did not taste right? Peanut butter It's like you changed if flavoring or something from the last one you used to scary
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
25 March, 2026Verified purchase
Peanut butter
I’m not impressed. This peanut butter is so thick it’s almost impossible to stir ( yes it’s a no stir ) and it rips the bread and does not spread well at all. It’s good for a smoothie that’s about it .
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
21 March, 2026Verified purchase
Check the ingredients!
I usually like and trust the Good and Gather brand. Got home and saw that there is palm oil and sugar in this. So disappointing. Good and Gather, do better! All you need is peanuts and salt to make PB! The texture is dry. Will not be buying again!
5 out of 5 stars
9 March, 2026Verified purchase
(no review title)
Tried this brand instead of the plans was blown away how tasty and creamy it is. great value
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
5 March, 2026Verified purchase
Do NOT Buy!
I got this at an amazing discount and of course I will use it all but it genuinely tastes so gross. Next time even if it’s on sale I will not be buying this one. Maybe I’ll like it by the time I need a new one. But for now it is not good.
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
25 February, 2026Verified purchase
Far Too Dry
This peanut butter is priced very well, but it's texture has been poor for a while... It's far too dry, with not enough peanut oil. This makes it pastey, like sucking the moisture from your mouth. It also causes the peanut butter to be much harder to spread without smashing of tearing bread. Seems like it'd be an easy fix...
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
21 February, 2026Verified purchase
(no review title)
I purchased because the price was great for the fact that it didn’t have hydrogenated oils in the ingredients! Good flavor!
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
17 February, 2026Verified purchase
Didn't taste like anything I've ever had.
I’m fairly new to natural peanut butter, but I understand it separates and has a slightly different texture than regular brands. That wasn’t the issue here. The moment this hit my mouth, I had to spit it out. The taste and overall sensation were completely unbearable. It didn’t taste like peanuts at all. It wasn’t just “different” — it was shockingly off. There was no second try. One bite was more than enough. I don’t know if I got a bad batch or if this is how it’s supposed to taste, but I couldn’t use it and ended up throwing the jar away. Very disappointing.
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
17 February, 2026Verified purchase
(no review title)
Used to be our favorite but they must have changed the formula. We're switching brands now.
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
16 February, 2026Verified purchase
(no review title)
Used to be good, but either formula changed or there was a bad batch.
1 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
11 February, 2026Verified purchase
Terrible
Worst peanut butter I’ve ever had. Almost doesn’t even taste like peanut butter. Very processed.
2 out of 5 stars
25 January, 2026Verified purchase
(no review title)
Weird texture - other brands definitely better