Ulta Beauty Collection Classic Felt Tip Liner - Black - 0.016 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

I genuinely really love this eyeliner! I was going to take my engagement photos and was searching for a long lasting eyeliner to wear since I was going to be hiking and sweating (we were camping, brave I know). I tested a few eyeliners on my hand, including this one. This one stayed on through rubbing and wetting. I wore it for the photos and I've been wearing it to my very active job. Stayed out through everything. I love it.

The eyeliner is a great formula but after a month of use, the cap will not stay on and it drys out. Would love to keep buying it but it's wasteful not to be able to use it fully.

I loved this product most especially for a long wear! I was so impressed also because I Went to steam sauna and it stays intact. Amazing!

Really good product! 10 of 10

I returned. I'm a senior so maybe it's my skin? The liner did not adhere, and flaked off.

I have purchased this product many times. It flows well and lasts long.

Great price for a precise pen!

It used to be very good quality and was on par with higher end lines. Now, the lid pops off on its own in my drawer and dries out. This has happened several times. My newest one isn't going on like the old ones used to. I see a difference in the quality of this product.

I have been using this liner for years but the last two I have bought- the caps just randomly pop off and they wind up drying out. This never used to happen before so i guess they changed something with the packaging but i'll no longer purchase it.

Love this eyeliner

Im starting to use eyeliner again and i picked this because its on sale and it had the color I wanted. Honestly this has lasted me for so long. This closes fine and I store it upside down. I have had no issues using it but Ive only used brown no other colors. I would still suggest it if youre getting back into using eyeliner or if its your first time.

Im starting to use eyeliner again and i picked this because its on sale and it had the color I wanted. Honestly this has lasted me for so long. This closes fine and I store it upside down. I have had no issues using it but Ive only used brown no other colors. I would still suggest it if youre getting back into using eyeliner or if its your first time.

I wanted to love it and give this eyeliner a chance cause most of all the Ulta products have not disappointed me but this one is not for me. The tip bleeds out the second you apply it. It doesn't last much longer. You are better off with NYX eyeliner.

I really like this eye liner because I can get it on very thin. Plus it has those metal balls inside the tube to keep it mixed like the ones in nail polish. I've tried a few different brands and always come back to the Ulta brand because it outlasts other brands and it's easy to apply. I highly recommend this liner.

Ive tried some of the top brand eyeliners and this is by far one of the best ive used!!

I have bought this eyeliner for a couple of years and love it however they must have changed the packaging recently. The lid pops off and will not stay on. This causes it to dry out and I have to throw it away when I have barely used it. Ultra check the packaging!!

I am a brown eyeliner girl and apparently brown eyekiner is super hard to find. I was previously using the elf brown eyeliner and it discontinued so I had to find an alternative. I stumpled upon this one right before checkout and took a chance, and i dont regret it! I love how bold and long lasting it is, the elf eyeliner would desipate with the slightest touch, while this one LASTS. Im so glad i found this one ulta please never stop making it !

I have to wedge the pen between things to try & not have the top fly off. can't travel w/it.

5 stars for the stay-all-day liner. I love it. 3 stars because the cap will NOT stay on. This is my second liner in a month and both of them had caps that fly off drying out the tip. I've been using this product for years and never had a problem before.

I have been buying this eyeliner for years. The formula is fantastic; it is a deep black, doesn't smudge, and doesn't irritate my eyes (5 stars for the makeup itself). However, as other reviewers have said, the cap "pops" off after about 3 weeks of use (due to small cracks that form in the plastic cap), and then the product dries out on the felt tip (ZERO stars for the pen/cap)! I am now forced to throw this away, with so much product left in the pen. Something must have changed over the past 6 months, as this used to never happen. ULTA - please do better and check the manufacturing of this eyeliner. It is such a great product for an great price, and it deserves to have a cap that stays on so that valued customers can continue to enjoy this-- I feel forced to reluctantly switch to a different brand.