ESSENCE Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner - 0.04oz

Not a bad eye liner, but how do you sharpen this or lift the gel pencil? Once you use the first point of the pencil, is that it?

PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD FORMULA THAT STAYS PUT! This version is drying and doesn't last as long. ALSO BRING BACK THE DARK GREEN!!! 😭😭

The pencil goes on nice and smooth. Is not the longest lasting, but for the price I expect that. It does sharpen, just try it people! Maybe some don’t think so because it’s encased in a plastic type material(?) but it does. Anyway, I’d buy it again overall

I tried to sharpen it with cosmetic sharpener but it's not working. I bought essence Duo sharpener thought maybe works better no chance

Essence should be ashamed, selling a product that can’t be sharpened or twisted up. I used this three times and can’t use again. Ridiculous.

It's nothing.. it disappeared in 30 seconds!! I couldn't even do the other eye .. and couldn't sharpen it It's a plastic pen, kept cracking!! Worst eyeliner ever

I bought the gel eyeliner and I really like it. But! You get, like, a 1/4 of an inch! I feel like there’s more in the pencil, and, if so, how do I get it out?? It doesn’t twist and you can’t sharpen, so what am I missing??

Its okay, not like before

It sharpens well but the color is not consistent. It’s not buildable and looks streaky.

I LOVE IT better then the other ones I tried some different brands and this get my # 1

I got this for my tightline my waterline because I saw that this was a dupe for the Urban Decay Legend. This eyeliner not only tightlines brilliantly, but I also used it to make the smoothest, sharpest winged liner and it didn't smudge or fade.

What happened to the extreme lasting liner???? Bring back Black Midnight Sky

I love this liner! I bought a neutral color for my waterline (I'm a tired stay at home Mom and it covers up the redness). It stays on in my waterline literally all day. It's still there when I go to wash my makeup off at the end of the day - do it's on over 12 hours. When I run out of my more expensive black liner I'm definitely replacing that one with this brand! Bonus- it goes on smoothly with no tugging

Smooth, creamy, pigmented and has a good wear time; I have watery eyes and this holds for up to 3 hours for me before it starts to fade.

Website says to sharpen it but it has a plastic tip and no way to push more out to be able to sharpen. I lol be the color and the feel of the product but what a waste.

It’s a beautiful color however, it does not last up to 16 hours as stated and it does fade when wearing.

Glides on very easily, doesn’t drag or leave gaps. Lasts all day. The espresso color is not as harsh as black so it’s good for everyday wear. At this price point, don’t expect miracles. But it does the job.

Im not happy with this product. I cant sharpen it, and it also has no turn function at the bottom to make the pencil come up...

i purchased this as a new line to try. i love the rasin color as i have green/blue eyes and its a color that is a go to for me. the first time wearing it it was ok i use it on my upper waterline as well as lower.. it clumped in my lashes and bleed onto my skin. i was not outside nor sweaty. By the end of the day it had made its way to the corners of my eyes!!! i tried it out a few more times. did not go on and stay in place as i used it more. now its rounded and i used the sharpener and that made the tip fall off so i had to sharpen more. it fell off again as i was reapplying it. I'm not at all impressed with this product aside from the color.

I love this nude eyeliner! It really does stay on all day on my waterline and brightens and widens my the look of my eye. My only negative is that it doesn’t last long! It looks like it would be a pencil that twists to reveal more product but it does not.