e.l.f. No Budge Matte Eyeshadow Stick - Thrift Shop - 0.05oz: Vegan, Paraben-Free, Eye Lid Application

works perfect and stays forever!!

Perfect for a busy mom, who just wants to swipe on some color quickly during a busy morning! Wonderful pigment, stays all day long. No primer needed.

This is an OK shadow stick. The color thrift shop is more yellow than the website indicates. It’s more of a khaki than a tan or brown.

Very similar to the Nyx shadow stick I threw out. Important note is I have oily eyelids. I figured after the Nyx experience that shadow sticks probably just aren't compatible with my lids, but all the color variety is going into sticks these days, and this one said it was good for all skin types, so I decided to give it a chance. I did not have a great time, but it's possible that the experience could be improved with the addition of some specialty products. Pros: Much easier and quicker to apply than an eyeshadow palette. Fits better in my to-go makeup pouch than a palette and brush set. Nice earthy shade of brown that looks a little greenish on my skin in warm lighting. Features a convenient built-in sharpener (did not test it so I don't know how well it works). Mixed: The application looks messy and rough and does not blend easily. Great if you're into an edgier look but not so much if you want a smoother smoky eye. Personal preference really. Cons: Melts and creases after a few hours. Granted I tried it without a primer or setting spray to test the claim that it's long-lasting; maybe it would hold up better with some help. Biggest downside is how hard I had to scrub to take it off. Two rounds of water-based cleanser and a third with a makeup removal wipe. I know there are oil-based products that might make this easier (e.l.f. recommends their cleansing balm), but my skin is too sensitive for all that extra cleaning. I don't think I'll be wearing this product again. I don't especially like the way it looks, and my eyes have to take a beating to remove it.

This has to be the worst shadow stick I have ever used. It was dry, patchy and honestly with all the work I had to do made my eyes hurt. Don’t recommend!

Absolutely stunning it applies smoothly and effortlessly.

I bought this in vintage suede thinking it would be a nice neutral to add to my eye shadow options. Nope. It’s yellow. Makes me look like I have jaundice.

Easy to use as an eyeliner,kohl or eyeshadow I was so impressed.

I like the color easy, to apply and long lasting

Glides on lovely, decent saying power, fab colour, excellent price. I have 5 shades xx

I liked the look of a ‘beige’ base colour for a no-budge eye-shadow. This vintage suede is HORRIBLE!! It’s basically a mustard yellow colour. Not worth my time or money to return it but if that colour is so mis-matched then I wouldn’t trust the others either. Very disappointing

Does not go on smoothly at all. Have to use too much pressure and drag it on my eyelids.

Purchased this for a neutral look and it’s a yellow color. Not flattering at all. Definitely not as pictured.

A rare disappointment from ElF, purchase in Cool Beans, it’s hard to work with and lacks any colour density. I’m super pale but it lacked impact and stayed sticky to touch.

This is THE WORST eyeshadow that I have ever purchased! It's IMPOSSIBLE to apply-- it really WON'T "budge" across the eyelid!!! I tried a brush applicator, a sponge applicator, a silicone applicator, and my own finger-- NONE of them could spread the shadow! And since I don't need to be aggravated by eyeshadow application on a daily basis (life is too short!), I'm tossing this in the trash--an unfortunate waste of money and product. :-(

Maybe because I didn't use a eyeshadow primer but it does not stay in place at all. Please tell me other brands dont move. It move around so bad it looked awful after an hr. Sad 😥

This is gorgeous. I absolutely love these. The color goes on easily and stays all day. I wish there were more colors!

So I tried out the no budge, shadow stick crayon and I love the color. After a while, the color fades, though it does not budge. I thought it was OK.

These bold crayons are perfect for lids and under eyes

I like the colour I chose as an easy everyday look but I found it to feel sticky, even when I put powder shadow over it