One Trick Pony Organic Smooth Peanut Butter - 16oz

kids favorite!

Amazing….obsessed and overpriced.

Creamy delicious, premium and well made

Best peanut butter I’ve ever had! Sooo smooth, a little pricey but quality is worth it!

Peanut butter was good and great price for organic. But no matter how perfect you put the lid on and store it flipped, oils leak everywhere. Impossible to keep clean.

I like that is super creamy and the jar concept works. Only a couple of ingredients is a win-win.

This is the best peanut butter with minimal ingredients Worth the price! Highly recommend.

Never thought I’d be writing a review for peanut butter but I want everyone to buy this so that it stays stocked. This peanut butter is perfect. Sooo creamy. I’m truly amazed it’s just peanuts and salt.

Best peanut butter ever!!!

Tastes like a musty old house smells. Not sure how you make peanut butter this bad.

This is probably the worst peanut butter I’ve ever tried. There was some weird after taste that I have to brush my teeth to get rid of. I love the healthier options but I recommend trying Santa Cruz dark roast if you want a healthier peanut butter.

I am a PB-holic. I will scoop out spoonfuls and eat it neat. I was excited for the ingredients, or lack there of, and interested in the special container that keeps it from being refrigerated or separating. this has made me seriously decrease my PB intake, which may not be the worst thing lol, but it disappoints me when I'm craving some and I get some but it's not how I want it. Cons: I keep getting a slightly floral? (only way I can describe it) taste. I thought it was a one off cause of something I drank or ate with it, but each time I've tried it I get the flavor. you have to turn it right side up for a little while before opening the jar because it will open to a mess if you're hasty with it. I usually smack the top and then let it sit, but with two toddlers we don't have a lot of time to wait. Pros: doesn't separate, clean ingredients, sweetness and everything else could be great, I just keep getting turned off by the floral notes. My kids don't seem to mind the taste, so I may keep buying just for the simple ingredients.

Best peanut butter ever, no palm oil which is a plus. Went through the jar in less than a month. I absolutely love the flavor the texture/runnyness.

I don’t know how peanut butter can taste bad. We’re a PB family and I always buy brands that are just peanuts and salt- no added oil or sugar. And I’ve never tasted PB like this. My son tried it and said it tasted like mold. I’d describe it as dirt. Save your money and don’t buy.

The texture is not creamy at all! There was a 1-inch thick peanut butter “plug” it the bottom/top of the jar that when I punctured, dropped into the jar of runny peanut butter/oil. I tried mixing but now it’s runny, chunky peanut sauce and can’t be spread on bread. The flavor isn’t great either. Barely tastes like peanuts at all. Going back to Justin’s.

The peanut butter meets all my dietary restrictions, it's peanuts and some sea salt. No sugars or additives. what is the drawback to this is the container, very difficult to store without it creating an oily mess on the pantry shelf. I have arthritis and if you don't get the lid on perfectly straight it takes forever to get open. I had peanut butter and oil all over my hands and the counter. I used 4 paper towels before I finally "broke the code" to use it. If they offer the product in an alternate container I'll probably buy it again, just not in this jar.

The taste is on par with other natural peanut butters I have tried. What sets this apart is the texture! There is no oil separation, which in the past would annoy me. The texture is indeed silky smooth. I’m glad I found this while just browsing my local Target, and will be sticking with this peanut butter for the long haul.

The design of the container is genius! The easiest *natural* peanut butter to get out of a jar without struggling to stir!

Love how smooth and creamy this PB is. It spreads perfectly.

Nice texture, great ingredients but very light in flavor. Missing a tad bit more salt. Would not purchase again.