Medela Silicone Breast Milk Collector with Stopper, Suction Base and Lanyard - 3.4 oz

I have two haakkas and one of these. This specific one is a terrible design. The smooth edge on the opening doesn’t give any grip. It falls off easily. & let me tell you when this falls off and you have a bunch of breast milk in it, it’s devastating. Compared to the haakka, I would stick with the Haakka’s design. This is a no brainer for me. Whoever said don’t cry over spilled milk clearly never breastfed.

Used this during early months of breastfeeding to collect excess milk on the other side while feeding. Loved this, recommend grabbing two.

One of my favorite daily breastfeeding tools. I just place it one side while nursing on the other. It is the perfect way to collect let down milk. It safe easy and convenient!

I gave this two stars because it does work -- if you hold onto it constantly. It's a piece of trash compared to the Haakaa though -- don't buy it thinking to save money like I did. It doesn't suction well and just lets go randomly even if I'm not moving. Likewise, the suction cup on the bottom, which I had high hopes for, does almost nothing to keep this thing anchored to surface when you're done using it. I got three ounces out of it by holding onto it and re-suctioning every 15-20 seconds. Do yourself a favor and spend a little bit more to get the Haakaa instead. Don't bother with this.

I have the haakaa and I wanted a second one so I figured this one was cheaper so why not give it a try! Well don’t move or honestly sit still it pops off randomly n

Works very well! Just be careful to properly place the suction over all of your nipple area, as it can cause some serious pain.

I love Medela’s manual pump the Harmony so I figured I’d give this a shot, but the silicone milk collector was a fail. The material and design seemed impressive upon its unboxing, however the suction in comparison to the Hakka was extremely disappointing and I’ve lost milk with this. I would not recommend this product and now I am stuck with a product I am unable to use and return due to poor functionality.

Just buy the haakaa one. I’ve lost milk from this thing not suctioning properly.

Horrible, we bought this haakaa as I have one at home but forgot it while out. Well you get what you pay for; this is not like my other haakaa, it looses suction almost immediately and doesn't do the job correctly. Holding it on as we speak.

Works well! Stays on great, easy to put on and empty.

Good suction, easy to use. Gets the job done.

I’ve spilt so much milk that I’ve collected because this constantly falls off. Horrible suction

The silicone is much more rigid than the traditional haaka. This means the plastic digs in and is very uncomfortable. It does what it’s supposed to but I can’t use it due to the discomfort.

I have a different brand of these that has been amazing and liked that this came with a lanyard to keep around your neck. My daughter tends to knock these off when in use but this has been the worst purchase. It doesn’t hold suction at all.

It worked very well at first. I collected a lot of milk. However, overtime it loses suction and it is very difficult to catch anything.

Don’t do it! This product is made well but doesn’t suction at all, your milk will spill everywhere!

I LOVE this it collects so much milk!

This product is made of quality material, however there are flaws in th e design. If you use this, be ready to cry over spilled milk. 1) The size of this product is tiny. It holds less than the Haakaa manual breast pump volumetrically. So more discrete, but more dumping need. 2) The included neck strap is required for use. The breast flange is smooth in design and doesn’t have the ribbed collar that the Haakaa does. This means the suction on this product doesn’t exist and makes it constantly fall off. So if used in the shower to catch your let down in a warmer environment, it will constantly fall off. This poor suction will also make it easier for it to release and fall off if bumped, like by little feet if nursing on the other side. 3) The accessories are nice, but the flawed design make it hard to justify the purchase. Save yourself the frustration and get the Haakaa.

Does not stay on as well as hakaa or even lansinoh . I will have this brand on one side and the hakaa on the other. This one constantly pops up and I spill milk everywhere

Shameless knock off of original haakaa design