OXO Glass Deep Dish Pie Plate with Lid

I absolutely love this pie pan! The pan, itself, is well made and has a good heft to it. It’s also nice and deep. I used my red Farberware Baker’s Advantage ceramic pie plate for several years; however, I have been wanting to try out a glass plate for a few different reasons. Over the years, I have perused the various highly-recommended glass pie plates, but none of them were deep enough for my liking. I recently searched again and discovered this bad boy. It was plenty deep, was made by a brand I trust, AND came with a lid! Bonus! I immediately ordered one. To my dismay, when it arrived, and I opened it up, I discovered that the plastic lid was cracked. It is unfortunate that such a nice, beefy pie pan comes with a flimsy plastic lid. Luckily, however, this product is covered under OXO’s “Better Guarantee.” Best of all, you can file a claim online—no having to deal with a nightmare 800-number call. The Better Guarantee warranty form can be accessed here: https://faq.oxo.com/contact/warranty-form-oxo-SkjU7fn8q. I filed my claim and heard back from OXO customer service in only one business day. They confirmed that my lid was covered under their Better Guarantee and then told me that a whole new pie pan with lid was already on the way! My new pan/lid arrived a mere three days later, and this second lid is fully intact. So, while the lid is flawed, OXO stands behind their products and will replace your lid—well, apparently you get a whole new pie pan too. I have decided to give this pie pan an overall 5-star rating but a 4-star rating on quality based on the lid alone. The pan, itself, is definitely a 5-star product when it comes to quality.

Lid came broken, despite being well packed

The glass pie dish is 5 stars. The lid is one star. It only rests on the pie dish. A lid for glass should fit and seal to the dish - otherwise what's the point. One can cover with a piece of foil or plastic wrap or rest a plate on it. And there are vents in the lid- not desired when one wants to limit air flow and maintain freshness.

I bought this for the lid. And happy I did it great to be able to cover the pie in the dish. Especially great for cream pies.

Lid has holes. Did not see that listed in description. Makes lid useless for my needs.

As others have said before, the lid came broken, the pie plate is great- I just wish it had a lid.

I love how deep this pie dish is! And the lid makes for easy transport.

Surprisingly sturdy and good quality

Love the vented lid.

I purchased these with lids because I wanted lids for my pies after baking. I go tired of using foil or other types of homemade coverings. I love pyrex and love that the lid has holes so the pie does not keep in moisture and make the pie crust wet and mushy. Highly recommend if you are looking at these as you will not be disappointed.

They got it ready for pick up but it’s brand new had a crack on the lid then decided get refund. Wish they had stronger lid without crack.

Dish holds a deep dish pie, bakes even. Cover is nice for storage or to take along

Great in theory. Unfortunately, I didn’t *actually* get to use it, because it arrived with a cracked lid. I returned it, but all my local Target stores were sold out, so I wasn’t able to get a replacement.

Love this product for my sis !

and the lid is amazing. I needed a deep pie dish for an almond custard pie I was making and happy that this was in stock at my local target. definitely recommend.

I needed a deep dish pie plate for a peanut butter pie. Pie plate is good quality and having a lid is a fantastic addition. Will be buying more for my kitchen.

I will be returning this pie plate because it is not deep as advertised.

Lid fits on very loosely

Makes great pies, and the fact that has a lid makes it even better to store leftovers

I love this pie set, it’s so great when transporting pies. If you’re a pie maker, you need one of these, or two. Seriously love this so much.