e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen - Waterproof - Jet Black - 0.02 fl oz

Takes a lot of effort to get a good line and wing. Dries really fast and crumbly and cracked when it does dry.

I was hopeful for the new brown color since I don’t like applying the inkwell version and really takes me longer than using a pen style. But the color brown is just not flattering on me. So disappointing. It’s light, warm toned and doesn’t look right on my eyes or the cool tone neutrals I wear. I love the caffeinated dark brown color for the inkwell version of H2O formula. Please make it in the pen style. I have terribly watery eyes in the morning since I get up at 4:30 for work. And if I use the heat in car it makes my eyes water and I still have eyeliner on afterwards because the H2O formula really stays on! It’s tricky to get off at end of day but why I like it.

I have tried several marker-style black liners for tightlining along my lash line, this one is excellent and very long lasting. Nothing is perfectly waterproof but this one does stick very well.

I run 70 miles a week and compete in some pretty intense competitions and conditions, and I pair this eyeliner with Elf's Big Mood waterproof mascara. Both do not budge, like at all! I can put it on early in the day, race, and go out after and do not need to reapply. My teammtes always ask what eyeliner I use because it always looks great after lol.

horrible not waterproof. bought this to fill in gaps between strip lashes n my natural lashes n it makes a MESS n gets all in my waterline and literally ruins my makeup, leaving black smudgy stains all over my eyelid. horrible horrible HORRIBLE

Surprisingly I’m in shock that this eyeliner is good I gave it four stars because I wanna see how long it will last me I wanna compare with the NYX COSMETICS but so far it’s good I have no complaints and it’s a good cost 👍

I bought this looking for a brown eyeliner, sadly it doesn’t go on smoothly and looks bumpy when applied. The pen itself isn’t very precise as the product does not seem to distribute across the pen evenly for application, making it hard to touch up areas that may have come out thinner than expected or completely been missed due to the pen itself. I’ve used eyeliner for years, so I know this isn’t an application issue, rather a product issue.

It stays on really well, but is a bit hard to get a thin line with

I love this eyeliner. It’s really easy to use, and overall just super pigmented. It definitely is waterproof, I’ve cried like a baby with it on, and it didn’t smudge at all. Love it!

Smooth, dark and easy to apply. Great pigment, stays all day Love it!

This eyeliner would be absolutely perfect if it didn't keep exploding in my eye and making my eye completely black and getting onto my contact lenses. There's gotta be a better way to package this!

Love how durable it is, and love the shade and also I would love if it was a bit more darker brown.

I bought this pen bc the eyeliner I was using wouldn't stick if I put lotion on my face. I use the elf brow gel, and it's way better than the expensive stuff, so I was like, let's give the eyeliner a try. Not only did it go on like butter, it looked amazing, made me feel like a queen. On top of that, my allergies made my left eye water all day, no smudges. Later, I cried my eyes out because men suck. Still there. I then used my electric face scrubber with my face wash before bed. While it did get most of it off, there was a very stubborn part that was like, no ma'am. Men won't stay, but this eyeliner will definitely try. 10/10 recommend.

Transfers/crumbles after drying for 5+ minutes. Eyeliner starts to leak after opening cap.

Fabulous pigmented eyeliner that glides on with no colour skipping and stays put. Please keep this eyeliner in stock as it is the best I've tried in a very long time

Don't know how I only found this eyeliner this year. I've been spending all sorts of $ at other brand names only to have the liner smeared and running down my eyes within hours. This pen not only stays but it's fine tip allows for great wings. This is the best. I will continue to buy and only buy this brand.

This is the smoothest eyeliner I have ever tried to put on!

Good product it just starts to bubble and leak after multiple uses. that's my only con with this product, but I'm on my 3rd or 4th liner.

I am definitely a big fan of elf products and this eyeliner blew my mind. It’s so smooth, pencil applicator and easy to apply. Glides on the eyes easily. Waterproof, smudge proof, and super long lasting until you remove it literally. I love love this. Definitely worth buying and won’t brake the bank either. Highly recommended.

Easy to apply, good for any makeup look - highly recommended