Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Dark Brown - 0.033 fl oz - Ulta Beauty: Defining, Eye Area Application

This is my go to liner

This is the best eyeliner ever. I makes all my makeup looks, look amazing.

Comes off in the corners of my eyes. Like every other eyeliner out there. The only ones that ever worked for me were the old Maybelline waterproof in the blue tube. And kat von d ink well before she sold the company. I'm bummed out I wanted to like this, but yeah it just doesn't say. It will stay on top, but it doesn't stay where it needs to to be a waterproof eyeliner

Do not waste your money on this. First of all, this product hardly had any product come out on the FIRST try right after I opened it. Brand new packaging and still nothing substantial came out. And the color that did come out was more of a light black or a gray. Not dark at ALL. The white was a pretty color but didn't last at ALL, much like the black. Staying power is awful. And all for that price??? Do not waste your money I promise you will be disappointed.

It's been awhile since I used this one. I'll stick to what I know

I've been using this eyeliner for years. I love the easy application and the sharp color. However, it is not long lasting and smudges with every blink. It only takes an hour or two for the lines to no longer be clean and sharp. It isn't worth the price if it's just going to smear.

This works fine but despite being waterproof it doesn't last forever.

I will forever repurchase this eyeliner. I buy one once every year and it is 100% worth it. Its long lasting and smudge proof, while also easy to clean up and take off at night. The dual tip allows a super precise wing.

Easy to use. Love the double ended tip.

Looking for a replacement for the KVD trooper eyeliner that has changed. Really nice easy application and no smear. Happy to find this replacement.

Did not stay on for 15 minutes. Smudged and had raccoon eyes by the time I left my home.

I have used regular single color Stila liquid eyeliner for years- black & colors. Tried the blue and teal shades cuz loved the idea of two colors in 1 tool for travel. Unfortunately the product dried out quickly. Don't know if it's due to product formula or packaging, but i wont buy this again. I'll stick with their standard single colors.

I used Stila's original liner for years until they changed the formula. It wasn't just a bad batch either because I bought multiple from different stores. I moved onto other liners that performed well. Last year, I found the microtip, loved it and a salesperson turned me onto the dual ended pen at the beginning of this year. Well, my last pen has been AWFUL. I've been using this new pen for 3 weeks. It's watery, transfers to my bottom lid (which the previous pens in this line hadn't done), and the thicker tip has dried out and started peeling. Excuse me?! The ink in the last pen stayed put and lasted me a while. That's why I kept repurchasing it. They changed the formula again, and this is very disappointing. I used to love this brand's products since 2004 but it keeps going downhill. I'm done with this brand.

This product is pricy and advertised as stay all day, but it literally smudges and smears off not long after applying. It always ends up all over my eyelids by the end of the day.

This is easily applied to eyes and stays on

This not only feathers but it is not even a little bit water proof. it came off so fast with a tiny bit of moisture. I was very disappointed.

Love this waterproof eyeliner duo. I have it in several colors. My eyes are always watery but the color stays intact! Glides on beautifully.

I've been using Stila for 3-4 years & I just purchased a new one about 2 weeks ago & it is NOT the same. It doesn't go on as dark & it doesn't last ALL day like I'm used to. Super disappointed, looks like I'll have to find a new go-to liquid liner.

Love being able to stack the colors with the broader midnight and super fine periwinkle.

I bought this and had to return as fine tip didn't work. The replacement one I got also did not work when they tested for me at the checkout. I got a full refund. There is a defect which is sad as I use the single end fine tip all the time. Love the idea!