Stila Stay All Day Matte Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - 0.016 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

Purchased this liner hoping it would stay all day as advertised. It did not. I didn't even get a few hours out of it before it was smudging under my eyes. So disappointing. No better staying power then the local pharmacy products

I've been using Stila's liquid eyeliner exclusively for the last 10+ years. I believed in the formula so much that I never felt the need to try any other brands. Recently, I ordered 2 eyeliners and they were fine for the first few uses but quickly dried out. Normally, they would last me 2+ months of daily use. I thought it was a fluke so I reached out to customer service and they sent me replacements. To my disappointment, the replacements had the same problem. They were fine for the first few days but now are unusable due to lack of product. After so many years, I'm unfortunately going to look at other brands.

This product goes on well, once you get used to the fine tip and it generally doesn't budge. If you are like me and want to apply once that's it, this is the product for you! I've tried a lighter grey shade and either the item itself was dry or the color just is very dull. This one is wonderful!

I read an article boasting the "best liners out there". This was in the list. I was hesitant because of the price but thought, hey, if it really stays all day, it's worth it. Nope. Within 2 hours, I was missing my winged corners already. Had melted down the sides of my eyes. So my search continues for a truly "stay all day waterproof liner".

I have been buying Stila liquid eyeliner for years. Literally spending tons of money on it. This eyeliner was so awful i couldn't believe it. It didnt work from the start and im mad at myself for not returning it. I would never purchase the matte again

Ulta was out of my standard KVD tattoo liner so I bought the Stila matte liquid liner ad a backup. It was terrible! The liner dried out after just a few uses. Also, it didnt last all day and i found myself going over the liner with a black eye pencil. What an expensive product to not work. Save yourself the time and effort, get the KVD tattoo liner or the L'Oreal Cat Eye Liner.

Decided to splurge on this eyeliner and it was a struggle to get any product out. Very disappointing given the price tag.

Im a stickler for a fiercely SHARP wing tip. I can count on Stila's All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner to do the job. It withstands anything I throw at it and still leaves my wing looking just at rich and sharp as it did at 6am.

I have been using the satin stila eyeliner for years. I bought this one on accident but figured it would be fine. Just like many other uses, it dried up and stopped working very quickly. Won't make the same mistake again

I was shocked by the comments. I purchased after swatching with a sample. I used to use NYX liquid matte liner but recently I found that the liner dries quick in the tube, not as long lasting as it once was :( I have used KVD tattoo liner, I like it but after a while it fades and is completely gone from my inner corners. I tried this one and surprisingly loved it! So far it works good, very dark and love it!

Applied thin, not consistent and transferred in a short amount of time. I had to wipe it all off at work.

had high hopes for this.... doesnt nearly live up to its satin counterpart. liked the way this applied, but started transferring all over my lids very quickly and by the end of the day a majority of it somehow settled up in my crease :/ the regular stila stay all day has never done this to me.

First time grabbing this "mate" version of this ¬ even a month in and it's already dried out :/ I didn't even use it more than 3x super disappointing!

Doesn't apply well. Is thin, sticky, and smears almost instantly. Would not purchase this again.

Flakes/does not last the day. The tip of the applicator dries out after 1 use.

I have been using this brand for 8 years and this has been my favorite eyeliner. But, recently I purchased a new pen and the tip was dry, and the tip dragged on my eyelids causing choppy looking eyeliner. Very dissatisfied and disappointed

Had this eyeliner for about a week so far and it's already dried out terribly.

I used to use the KVD ink liner, switched to the stila classic stay all day liner because the kvd quality went down. Tried this and loved the super matte effect but the pen dried out within a week. i kept it top down to help, but it still dried out.

I don't buy much makeup, much less leave reviews on said makeup. However, this is the WORST eyeliners I've ever bought. I was convinced to buy it & stray from my better than sex liquid eyeliner - HUGE REGRET. I can't get this to go on consistently!!!

I love the way it truly stays on all day. No need to worry and touch up. It looked great and I always wear it especially on vacation trips