L'Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Precision Felt Tip Waterproof Eyeliner - 0.034 fl oz

The tip of this eyeliner is so dry that I can’t do any type of wing liner. It wipes away if you try to create a wider/ longer line.

This smears on its own! After wearing it for a few hours and after it smears its difficult to remove too. The lineur intense felt version prior was so much better. It never ran. Why not just make the prior version waterproof. THIS IS THE WORSE eyeliner i have ever used. The previous felt version was my go to that I used for years. BRING IT BACK! This liner is such garbage!!!

I tried this liner a while back once before. I guess I forgot how bad it is, because I just tried it again hoping for a different result. For one, the tip is too long, which I notice doesn't allow the liquid to reach the very end of the tip. I kept trying it on the back of my hand to see if putting some pressure on it would make the liquid come out, but it didn't. The liquid was only at the end of the liner, which made it awkward to apply. Needless to say, I won't make the mistake of purchasing it a third time. I was really hoping to like it, because I do like the idea of a felt liner or a brush liner. Maybe if the felt liner was shorter, it would work better.

I used this product and it smears badly or runs. Their liquid that they had in the gold tube was far superior and did not run or smear but it looks like they discontinued it and I’ll have to find another brand.

I hate this eyeliner so much! It’s impossibly to get a sharp line and it’s so patchy on my eyes. I typically can work with the worst of eyeliners, but this one is definitely the worst one I have ever used. If I can return this I definitely will.

The formula is great it holds its name. I have no problem with the formula itself. However the applicator itself is horrible. I tried to get that sharp wing at the end, but at the end of it nothing was coming out. And when the ink itself finally came out it was way past the thin tip which resulted in a fat blunt end instead of the sharp end I usually do. Great formula but needs a better applicator.

This eyeliner pulls sooooo bad!! It’s so dry right after opening. The color isn’t hardly grey, it just looks black. But the worst part is the pulling. My eyeliner looked like trash after using this.

Did the company test this product before bringing it to market? It smears. The tip is super sharp, but smearing is a deal breaker. I stopped using the item after the first try.

This is so easy to apply and lasts all day. It's hard to find a nice grey! This is the bomb!

Easy to apply, pretty shade of brown!

Been buying and using these for years. Bought a replacement for a pen that didnt last as long as usual (<1 year, usually they last 1+ year for me). The replacement only lasted me a handful of months, which is what prompted me to write this review. The tip has dried out and does that annoying dry-erase marker thing where if you do manage to get some product out onto your eyelid, you can rub it off dry-erase style by trying to continue to apply more over the same area. The formula of the liquid itself is long lasting enough for me. I sleep with my eye liner on and often only have to touch it up in the morning. The eye liner does not do that annoying thing where it scales up and flakes off/creates flakes you have to painfully pull off after only half a day or do, unlike some other brands I've bought (cough maybelline precise cough). But this quality is negated by how quickly the tip dries. Ive tried storing my pen correctly, flipping the felt around to try to get more product to drain into the tip, etc. to no avail. I also literally only wear mascara and eyeliner, so its not as though the felt tip is getting clogged with foundation or eye shadow from my skin. It just dries out.

Crumbles off after 30 minutes of wear from blinking unless you put primer on. Then it’s like an hour unless you touch it.

I love it! Application is easy and the color doesn’t transfer! Perfect!

I really like the way this applies, however it is in NO WAY waterproof or even smudge proof. And as a girl that cries and sweats a lot (IYKYK lol) this won’t cut it. Also difficult to make corrections with a q tip because it doesn’t wipe off easily. Instead it just makes a huge black ink splotch. As someone that’s been wearing liquid eyeliner for 15+ years, I really can’t see how this has as many good reviews as it does.

I bought this item twice, the 1st one I thougth that the cap had fallen by accident so I bought a 2nd. In fact, the eyeliner is great, but it happens the same again. I keep all my cosmetics on a bag and after some days I found it again without cap and completely dry. Poor quality

Tried this after L'Oréal stopped making my favorite liner. Hated it. The tip is always completely dry so you can't get the precision of an actual felt tip liner

One of my finest moments hugging a toilet and ralphing into the John, but this eyeliner stayed on point. 10/10 recommend for your white girl wasted nights.

Fantastic smoothly glides on. Lasts into the day. Overall great product. If it's like everything else good, they'll stop making it.

Love the green color but I will never buy again and in fact I just returned it! I put it on and it immediately started fading and running into my eyes, and I am a cat eye pro! Tried again and I didn't even get to the bus stop (10 mins) and it started running. I was a mess by time got to work and as usual everyone else looked fresh and ready to start work. Looks is most important at my job. People looked at me weird. Is this what L'Oreal is about??? I loved the color and was going to get others.

I like how this eyeliner looks on my eyes. You have to test it on your hand before to get the ink running smoothly.