tarte Maneater Waterproof Mascara - Black - 0.3 fl oz - Ulta Beauty: Thickening, Lengthening, Volumizing

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I’ve tried several different brands and types of mascara and Maneater is the best! It doesn’t irritate my eyes, clump or smear.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Loved how my eyes looked with this mascara but was very disappointed came off while wearing didn't seem waterproof.

It stays on so well and gives so much volume and length to my lashes. Id pick this product over fake lashes any day of the week. Love it and will buy again in a heartbeat.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I’ve used the regular version of this mascara for years and love it! It goes on so nicely and doesn’t get clumpy. I decided to try the waterproof version recently and it’s great!

Did not stay in place as well as I expected waterproof mascara to

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This mascara rubbed off on my skin and flaked all over.

Yes this mascara stays on longer than other mascaras I've tried

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have been searching forever for a new mascara that doesn't clump on my lower lashes. I finally found it! Thanks Tarte!

Those who dislike water-resistant mascaras tend to downgrade every brand, not just Maneater. They are also users of oily makeup removers, greasy moisturizers and hydrating foundations near their eyes. Then they blame the manufacturer if their eye makeup wears off. This mascara is reliable for everyday use. It washes off with soap. Make sure you remove all oily products from your lashes before applying, so the mascara sticks. If you're going in the pool, it's best not to wear any mascara at all. But if you do, then use L'Oreal Panorama mascara which is harder to remove.

I have dry eyes, and the regular formula of Maneater mascara will run When I use eye drops. I'm happy with the results of the waterproof formula.

I've always just used the regular Maneater and it was out, so I tried the waterproof… I love it! I usually can't wear waterproof mascara because my eyes are too sensitive and I wear contacts. I will continue to purchase this 🩷

This is a good product. It really works with someone who already has thick lashes. I don't see any big results when I use this product.

Literaly makes your eyelashes fall as you put it on. Thats all have and need to say.

Immediately comes off. Garbage. Waste of money.

Since I discovered this mascara, I won't buy any other brand. This mascara makes my eyes lashes look so pretty. They look like false lashes.

I don't understand the negative reviews. This mascara lasts me. all day, through humid days and sweaty workouts. I don't have experience swimming in it. I love how pigmented the black color is. You get results with one coat. It doesn't itch. It curls my lashes without a curler. I'm never without a tube. I've been using this for several years. I hope they don't discontinue it.

No smudging by end of day. Looks great.

I needed a nice waterproof option as everything else I used would fall onto my bottom eyelid. I like how it thinly coats my lashes and I can choose how much to build/thicken it up.

I really wanted to love this mascara … but I could not. The mascara smudges… in under 2 hours! And it definitely flakes as time goes on. The length and volume achieved are nice … but who wants to keep cleaning up under your eyes? Not me …

Mascara held up great when I needed a total eye flushing at work when sedation drugs accidentally squirted into my eye. Still looked great after the whole ordeal