Almay Multi-Benefit Mascara - Keratin Infused - 504 Black Waterproof - 0.24 fl oz: Hypoallergenic, Volumizing, Finish

The brush was bent when I pulled it out of the tube

Separates lashes well, make my lashes look longer

The formula is too dry and doesn't hardly go onto your lashes.

Almay Benefits Mascara does not irritate my eyes when wearing or not wearing glasses or sunglasses and covers easily.

Great application and light on my face. Perfect for an everyday look but can also work for an adventurous look with lashes.

Very goopy and clumpy, not good

I love this mascara. It gives me lashes with nice length and it washes off very easy. I haven't had any smudging or flaking. It looks very pretty. I have extremely sensitive eyes and this is one of the few mascaras I can wear, as it is very comfortable.

I’m disappointed in the change. I’ve used this for years and it is not the same. The wand is much thinner and the mascara just sits on the wand and goes on caked up and seems goopy.

I have very sensitive eyes, and this mascara does not irritate them.

This Mascara is hands down THE BEST!! I have Super Sensitive Eyes & there is Absolutely NO IRRITATION whatsoever. The brush is gr8, Applies perfectly, Lashes are full & long. BTW using the non waterproof formula. Easily removed with micellar H20. Love Love Love

i have been buying the multi for many years. I don't know what's going on with the cap, it keeps splitting and I am unable to close the mascara.This happened several times. I keep purchasing it and hope that the cap does not split.

Covers lashes well, good for sensitive eyes.

I bought this Almay product at my local drugstore yesterday because of its "hypoallergenic" advertising. It went on very clumpy and with visable dots of mascara. No amount of curling or brushing changed it. I had to remove most of it. Now, after about 15 minutes, my eyes have started to itch. Obviously, I won't be buying again.

I love the way it's thick and goes on quickly, however. Since day ONE when I stroke the lashes somehow the mascara is pulling my lashes out. I've used it now for 10 days and will take the other one back (because I bought 2 so wouldn't have to go back for a while) I've never had mascara do this before. I'll have to go back to my L'Oréal Luminous. So disappointed 😞

Gentle on my lashes with good coverage. Easy to remove at night without pulling out or damaging lashes. Waterproof mascaras are damaging, not nurturing!

I have been a loyal customer of this product but 1 month ago I went to buy it and the surprise was that it had changed its image and when I used it I realized that it was not just the image but everything: they made it very liquid, with a very different texture than the previous version and the worst of all My eyes burn (like with regular eyelashes), as if the components had also changed. It didn't improve at all, the previous version of the product was better

I love this mascara. I am a contact lens wearer and it doesn’t irritate my eyes and doesn’t run when I sweat in the summer.

I do thank you for fragrance free, but am very disappointed in Almay. 1) Why can't you make a brush that fits tightly in the tube so that when it’s removed the bristles rub tightly against the tube and hold only enough mascara to coat lashes, instead of your loose fit that allows way too much goopy mascara that I have to wipe it off the brush with a tissue? It’s like a paint brush dripping with paint that one applies to a wall without wiping excess off so it doesn’t drip down the wall. Women with dry and sensitive eyes do not want extra gobs on lashes for one thing and I should I not believe its intentionally wasteful by the manufacture? 2) Why can't you make it really clear, which are washable and which are waterproof? And which are fiber-free. I find the packaging of your blue, pink, turq and white confusing. Not sure which of yours are most sensitive compared to your hypoallergenic but delivers volume, length!!! but hopefully without any fibers? Is black brown 503 the only washable one? Why would one shade be waterproof in a genre of sensitive eyes you’re promoting? Is it impossible for you to write it on the packaging in a good readable size font? So many new products on shelves these days, it takes so much time to find what you THINK you’re looking for. I for one with dry and sensitive eyes want only fragrance-free, washable, fiber-free and would appreciate and applaud you for making the choice easy to find. I've bought Almay for many years, but am actively looking for another.

Or at least mostly waterproof. I still smudge a little bit in the outer corners after having worn it for about 8-12 hours, but tears/watery eyes don't make it run, which was my main concern. Only thing is, and this is probably because it's waterproof, this mascara goes on super, super dry. Like a tad flakey, almost. This doesn't matter to be because I wear strip lashes every day so my mascara isn't really seen, but between it going on dry and the brush being bulky enough to make non-messy application difficult, it's only okay at best. But, it didn't make my contact derm flare up the way that most mascaras do, so that was a huge win. I bought it because it was a few dollars cheaper than any other hypoallergenic waterproof mascara I could find.

Never reviewed a mascara before, but this one was so disappointing I felt compelled to. Incredibly clumpy on the brush. Very flaky. I have been using Almay for a number of years now and decided to try this one. Going back to my tried and true.