Milani Stay Put 16HR Eyeliner - Black - 0.01oz: Defining Use, Matte Finish, Eye Area Application, Single Container

It does in fact stay on all day. Also easy to apply.

Goes on smoothly but smudges for nothing, i dont touch my eyes and even just working at my desk, this will smudge and then it’s hard to remove from undereye. Would not buy again.

This is the BEST eye pencil ever. Please please please bring back the dark plum color!!!

It's a good eyeliner but just not for waterline.

Bought for my daughter since this is waterproof. First time putting on her waterline and made her eyes burn. Not a product for sensitive eyes.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Glides on easily, great for waterline and long lasting

Love Love Love this eyeliner!! Will never live without it. I have very sensitive eyes and I wear contacts. Milani is the only brand of eyeliner, shadow, and mascara that I can use without any irritation. BUT THEY NEED TO RESTOCK THE EYELINER COLORS BEYOND JUST BLACK AND BROWN - IMPOSSIBLE TO FIND THE OTHER COLORS. OR, WHY NOT ADD MORE EYELINER COLORS AND NEW SHADOW PALATES?? This eyeliner goes on super smooth and lasts me all day without the need for reapplication. Thank you Milani!! Please bring back the other colors of this eyeliner -- especially the navy and the dark red. I wish I had discovered them sooner so I could have a lifetime stash.

Stays put all day. Blends great, no smudging. Love it

Love how easy to apply and log lasting. Does not irritate my sensitive eyes!

Love this make. Many other brands need a pencil sharpener which causes a lot if wastage and the wooden outer casing scratches the eye. It lasts a long time, does not irritate the eye, is easy to remove and is great value for money.

I have one eye that waters constantly and one eye that is dry and I have to puy drops in three times a day. It has been nearly impossible to find an eyeliner that actually stays put. Let me tell you this is the holy grail of eyeliners. I am shocked that it stays put the entire day without smudging. I am so thrilled to find inexpensive eyeliner that actually does what is says. I have wasted sooo much money trying to find a waterproof eyeliner. I will never buy another eyeliner. A real plus is that it comes off easily with my cleanser. No tugging or pulling to get it off. One happy woman!!!!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Glides on smoothly and stays put. I like the dark brown color, 02 Semi-Sweet.

Love this eye liner! Looks gorgeous on and stays put!!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] It is very black and goes on smooth. I would buy this again

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Great eyeliner! It stays put and glides on very easily

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The eyeliner omg it’s amazing I recommend it smooth easy in your eyes

Omg this is the BEST LINER. Ive been looking for a good liner. I tried this one and i love it.

Smooth and easy to use. It stays put and it does not need a sharpener.

I’ve been using Milani’s Stay Put Eyeliner in 06 Silver Foxy for years, and it was hands-down my favorite eyeliner. The metallic silver shade was perfect for adding a pop of brightness to my eyes without being too bold. It glided on smoothly, stayed put all day, and always made my eyes look more awake and vibrant. I’m so disappointed to find out that this shade has been discontinued. I’ve tried other silver eyeliners, but none compare to the quality and color of Silver Foxy. Please bring it back—there’s nothing else like it!

One of my favorite eyeliners ever! Smudges easily for a smoky eye and doesn’t transfer or run. I wish it came in more colors, though.