ColourPop BFF Liquid Eyeliner - Grande - 0.019 fl oz: Defining, Eye Area Application, Matte Finish

I was hoping to find a cheaper option than the high end liner ive loved for years, but this eyeliner smudged SO bad on my upper lash line that I had to walk around with Q tips and clean up my lid all day (and even in the first hour" it didn't look good at any point. will just keep

The worst! You have to press down so hard for it to come out otherwise it just scrapes it off.

Been using this eyeliner for about 4-5 years and it’s my favorite. Love how precise the tip is, super affordable, doesn’t try out through the day, and great for people with oily skin because it doesn’t really smudge, but at the same time, its very easy to remove with makeup remover. It used to dry up kinda quick a few years ago, and I swear they remodeled it , so the ink lasts longer. I’ve tried many liquid eyeliners and this is the only one I like. Colorpop, if you see this, feel free to send me some liners haha.

Best eye liner I’ve ever used.

Thick, not precise and dries out immediately. All around, a swing and a miss.

it's so hard to find a good fine point eyeliner pen and this one is good quality - especially for the price. it goes on smooth, has a rich color and the tip is pretty fine and so far has kept its point, which is awesome

Dries out fast

I really like the shade of brown and the applicator however, I do have to set this with a powder because it does not last very long and tends to smudge if you do not set it

Numero uno has stayed on even after meltdowns over college and lasts all throughout boxing workouts. I've had people even ask if my liner was tattooed on because it stays so well. The felt tip doesn't fray easily like other liners and it doesn't irritate my dry skin. One thing I will note is the other colors like the brown and white aren't super pigmented and do come off a bit easier but they still are worth it. Definitely recommend this liner!!

This product is horrible. I used it once and it immediately went on sticky, unforgiving, and my eyelids kept getting stuck to the hood all throughout the day and leaving black lines. It got even worse when it came time to remove it. I’ve used my eye make up remover I’ve used a warm washcloth. I’ve used cleanser and nothing takes this off. It keeps smearing all over the place as if there’s some adhesive glue inside of it, which is really annoying, and my eyes are burning from scrubbing to try and get it off. Do not recommend at all…the WORST!

I love this product. Unfortunately, this arrived at my house with the packaging ripped open with the cap off. I can't use it due to safety concerns.

Very pigmented black. The tip is pretty good for a felt tip. But the formula is terrible, the tip either pools the liquid or dried up completely within seconds. So it ruins the look by dragging off the already placed liner. Then when you try to fix it with a qtip because of pooled liquid it smears terribly and stains the skin. Wouldn’t recommend the liner in any color.

I absolutely love this liner in black, so, when I saw a fun blue one on sale, I grabbed it. The black is still my tried and true, it goes on smooth and lasts all day, no issues. The blue was horrible! It bled the second I applied it, even getting into my eye!, and the color was awful to remove, smearing all over my face. I see why it was on sale.

Not fine tipped and irritating to eye

Terrible, goes on sticky, and smudges throughout the day in the crease. I believe my eye is also having a reaction from it. Will not purchase this brand again.

Perfect no smudge no smears love it

This is my all-time favorite eyeliner. Seriously. It stays all day, super easy to use, and glides beautifully. :)

Super sharp, lasting for my oily monolids in ultra humid Singapore heat. Super pigmented black (love this sooo much). This is the liner that help me perfect my wing liner technique.

Very natural brown colour that suits an everyday look, subtle but beautiful! This is my favourite eyeliner of all time, repurchased 3 times now! Felt tip makes it super easy to get a sharp wing and the corners of my monolid.

Long wearing bright colors. Love these!