Stila Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Eyeliner - Damsel Dark Brown - 0.01oz - Ulta Beauty

Does not go on smoothly or easily. It tugs on your eyelid when you try to put it on. It's like it's dried out, but goes on easily when i do it on the back of my hand. It's going back! Waste of money.

This product stays on all day. It doesn't disappoints.

My favorite new eyeliner. Goes on smoothly and blends easily. Stays on until I take it off, but is not difficult to remove. Great color options, too.

I am so happy to have found this color eyeliner. I have dark eyes and dark hair and wanted something that would pep up my eyes and this surely does it. It's a great color and has great staying power. I highly recommend.

Sales staff who are very knowledgeable

This eyeliner is a waste of money. After buying 3 and thinkong i did something wrong, its not me! Its the eyeliner.., This eyeliner breaks off in little tiny pieces. No heat, no damge, just breaks on its own! Waste of money

swatched well and pigmented on my hand but not on my actual water line or inner corner. had to keep trying go re apply and even then it wasnt pigmented and didnt last definitely not water proof. super disappointed.

This product leaves my eyes irritated and bloodshot for days following. It's unusable. I bought the shade saucy. So disappointing for such an expensive product.

Love this eye liner pencil. It stay on all day and looks fabulous

This is the best eyeliner I've ever used! Stays on all day and looks beautiful!!

My go to liner in Plumful! It stays all day!

I absolutely love this eyeliner in Plumful!! I wear it every day on my bottom lid. It really makes green eyes pop!

Love this pencil so far! It goes on smoothly and accentuates my lower and upper lashes without creating raccoon eyes during the day. Don't know why I didn't buy this eyeliner pencil sooner!!

This is a great eye pencil. Easy to apply especially for mature skin. Does not smudge and stays in place.

I am a girlie with SUPER watery eyes and could only use one brands eyeliner. But the problem was that it was liquid and i wanted a gel for my eyes. I tried this and it is magnificent i put it on my hand and rubbed, ran water on it, and tried to scuff it but it didnt move. This is definitely for the girls whose eyes are super watery. Only thing i would say is it it isnt the smoothest application BUT its not bad and i would happy trade that off for makeup that doesnt run.

This is such a disappointing eyeliner. The formula is dry, so its hard to apply a neat line. It takes several passes to fill in. It is hard to smudge out, despite the name, though it did smudge on its own throughout the day, despite the name. For the price, I'm considering returning. :( Wanted to love.

I was very disappointed with this liner, especially after reading others review saying it great for the waterline. Well it... not only wasn't not good on waterline (smudged very badly,) but also the pigment was very mid (took a couple passes to get even a decent amount of pigment.)

I liked this eyeliner when I first purchased it, HOWEVER, when I was about halfway through the eyeliner, it started breaking off when I tried to use it. I thought maybe it was at the end, but nope. There was quite a bit left and was completely unusable. Super disappointing.

I usually ask a sales associate for their advice when shopping in store as they are often able to recommend great products, unfortunately this one was a miss. I have tried this product multiple times and cannot get it to last in my waterline for more than an hour, the color payoff is not great either as I had to go over the same area several times when applying it.

Smooth like butter. Goes on without tugging.