ESSENCE Extra Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Pen - 10 Blackest Black - 0.04oz

Looove, lasted all day

Says it's a long wear but not even three hours later it wore off. Looked upon initial application.

Sat at my desk all day, eyes were smeared by noon.

Not waterproof

Highly recommend this eyeliner pen for beginners! I have several eyeliner pens but this is my go-to. Love the felt tip. After 3 months of weekly usage it hasn't dried out yet!

The Essence Extra Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner is a first time for me. For me, I bought it because of the Waterproof. It was affordable and I didn't have to break the bank.

Great lasting eyeliner! Love the easy flow felt tip!!

Look now I wear a lot of eyeliner but this worked genuinely for at most 3 days lol. I KNOW it still has product in it but you can only get it to come out if you mash it down, and that doesn’t work for sharp liner. The felt tip just doesn’t get any of the liquid at the tip after 3 uses. On the bright side, when you’re able to get the product out I did like the formula and felt it held up against sweat/oils.

I used to use the Maybelline tattoo eyeliner and then I wanted something different that lasted longer and I tried this product I had it on since yesterday morning didn't wash my face before I went to bed My eyeliner is still on Yes I know it's nasty not washing your face but it is 10:44 at night and I put this on yesterday morning and my eyeliner is still on no cracks no smudges it looks perfect I'd recommend this eyeliner to anyone absolutely obsessed. I would buy this over and over and over and I'm going to use it to replace my Maybelline tattoo eyeliner

If you like felt tip eyeliners give this a try! Felt tip eyeliners are my favorite and this resembles my all time favorite from Victoria’s Secret that is discontinued. This one is fine and pigmented and also easily comes off without staining. Also doesn’t smudge and is buildable.

I usually use the Wet n Wild break up proof version of this but I wanted to try this one out. It's not as pigmented and takes a few strokes to get a solid black line out of it. I will be going back to my other go to.

I never write reviews but thought people should be warned! I’ve been wearing liquid eyeliner for over 20 years and thought I’d give this one a try due to the low cost and decent reviews. The first time I wore it I noticed my eye lids were red and puffy when I removed it. Thought it was a fluke but wore it again a week or so later and they were even worse and even started to scab! I’ve never had an allergic reaction to anything ever and definitely never had an issue with liquid eyeliner or any make up for that matter. Proceed with caution!

Loved it and I am definitely gonna buy it again

I’m not a fan of the felt / spongy tip this liner has, but if that kind of tip works for you you’ll probably enjoy this liner! I’ve found it fells to store it upside down, but this tends to dry out pretty quickly. It stays on fairly well, especially for a $4 liner. If you’re sweating a lot, going swimming, crying, showering, I’ve found it doesn’t hold up well, but sometimes you want an eyeliner that’ll come off easy! Overall a good choice for baddies on a budget

I’m not usually picky with my products but this was pretty bad. It dries out very quickly even when I followed the instructions to leave it upside down. It also just looked streaky/patchy. Major pass.

I purchased and used a different Essence Eyeliner Pen and it was out-of-stock, so I purchased this one. It irritates my eyes. At first, I thought it was allergy or pollen, but I put it on when I had no symptoms and could feel the itch starting. I will try to find the first one eyeliner I used from Essence because that one is a 5 star.

Pleasantly surprised!!! I’ve always wanted to try this brand but was always really wary of buying it in store since I know it doesn’t come with outside packaging (I worry about the sanitation aspect of that, especially at my local stores - note: it doesn’t come with outside packaging but that’s how this brand is just FYI) I finally saw it online and decided to give it a go (I figured there’s a much lower chance for tampering buying online than in-store since target’s never done me dirty with online shipping). And I have to rave - I love this liner!! I’ve been doing a cat eye with eyeliner pens for 15+ years now and this pen is better than some of the (much) more expensive ones I’ve tried!!! I can’t believe it’s not talked about more (I barely found any reviews online for it - which, gotta say, surprises me bc this liner is so good). The line is sharp and rich, I haven’t had any problems with the tip using this for a full week straight like I’ve had with some pricier pens. It’s not entirely smudge proof (but holds up well through my workouts) - that’s not a con to me, tho. I don’t love hardcore waterproof liners bc they can be more difficult to remove; this comes off quite easily with a cotton pad and micellar water. I have pretty sensitive skin and eyes and didn’t have problems with this either. Will be repurchasing a couple more after I get done with this review :)

I got it because someone said it works well over metallic eyeshadow and it does. It's supposed to be stored standing up with the tip facing down, just something to keep in mind.

I love essence eyeliner. They are amazing. Particularly this one is very long lasting. The problem is that the pen is not great, the tip gets dry too easily and I can't have a smooth line. I have used other essence eyeliner with the pencil (or brush) and work perfectly, but every time that I try a pen one...I get disappointed.

I love how long lasting the liner is, and theres no smudging! Its had to find a liner like this one!