ZuZu Luxe Eye Defining Pencil - Obsidian - 0.04oz: Sulfate-Free, Phthalate-Free, Paraben-Free, Eyeliner Pencil

Took a risk in ordering and love it!

This indigo liner is hard and not at all creamy. It pulls my skin and looks like there's hardly any color there. Very disappointed in the poor quality.

I almost love this indigo eyeliner. I like the color a lot. The problem is that it doesn't work well. Instead of a smooth line, it is very flaky. It looks like just a ton of tiny wax flakes. If you pick off the flakes, there's nothing left. It also comes off pretty easily. The onyx works much better than indigo. I feel like this brand is very hit and miss. Some shades work well while others are absolute trash.

I agree with the high ratings on this. It is good as a natural eye liner. The pencil is somewhat hard, but it still shows up on your eye without having to go over it again much. This means it will last longer. Also, it is fine on my sensitive eyes (I’m sensitive to some natural eyeliners). You can create a precise line. Finally, it can be removed easily. I think it is good value.

This eye liner isn’t heavily pigmented and it didn’t have the staying power I was hoping for.

Love this eyeliner. I am trying to switch to all natural, clean beauty items. This went on so smoothly. I got this in the color Iguana and it is so stunning. I have green-blue eyes and pale skin, but I could really see this color popping on any eye and skin color. Going to try Indigo and Slate next.

I bought the slate pencil and so far I really like it. It goes on really smooth and lasts throughout the day. I was a little disappointed that it has more of a light blue tint than a gray color but I still like it. I have blue eyes and it really brings out the color. I also love this is a more "healthier" makeup.

This is a new item for me. Beautiful creamy green eyeliner, stayed put most of the day. Will definitely try rest of the product line. Used in the water line, no sensitivity as expected.

I ordered Iguana, which looks on the pencil like a grass green. I have been looking FOR EVER for a green that doesn't look blue once I apply it and FINALLY this one does the trick. I apply a very fine line on the outside bottom third of my eye and it is perfect! I have spent alot more money trying to find this exact result. Highly recommended.

I like this eye pencil in particular, as it's just right color for me and it leaves pretty sharp line. Not too soft, not too smooth, just what I need. Also it doesn't irritate my eyes, they are sensitive to most of cosmetics.

First, not sure why Target would list both the liquid and pencil eyeliner together as it took me a while to find it. The ZuZu liquid eyeliner is one of the best I've ever used and the ingredients are GREEN AND NATURAL! I've decided to go green with my skincare and cosmetics and while skincare products have been relative easy to find, green/natural cosmetics has been very hard to find that actually performs. Happy to report that the ZuZu liquid eyeliner performs, provided you prep your eyelids a bit. I have very oily eyelids and it stays on all day. I got the black and it is a true pigmented black. I'm going to be trying out the other colors soon too. It glides on smoothly and drys relatively fast. I love the applicator too, it's almost felt like? Highly recommend!