Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Waterproof Skinny Eyeliner - Black - 0.017 fl oz: Matte, Pencil Form, Defining Eye Makeup

This marker eyeliner is amazing. Doesn’t smudge at all, even of you rub it with your fingers. Stays put in heat, which is rare for my oily skin. Hard to find such a good eyeliner at this price. Doesn’t dry and lasts a long time.

I like it! I kind of wish it was a felt tip instead of a brush tip but that's just personal preference I suppose. It goes on nice and is buildable for a thicker result.

I have been using this eyeliner for years and I can 100% say that this has worked every single time. I constantly get compliments on my eyeliner for how long it stays. I can admit there’s been a couple times. I’ve slept with my eyeliner on and it has stayed on the next day. I’ve had people ask me where I got it from. They’ve taken pictures of the product and and I can confirm that I can always depend on this eyeliner to be my number one brand never switching to anything else❤️❤️

Not my favorite from wet n wild. It is not very black and lacks pigment, more like a sheer charcoal. Much prefer the liquid eyeliner to this. Precision is ok, relatively easy to use.

My go-to eyeliner. I have gone through sooo many eyeliners, yet this is the one i return to! Does not crease and is a nice, black color that doesn’t fade. You’re able to layer and build up on top of layers as needed, and doesn’t have that annoying smell that comes along.

This is THE best eyeliner. Any high class brand isn't anything on this.

Extra dark and lasts forever. My eyes water and usually my liners slip off. This lasts all day

I love the price. It works for me, it doesn’t smudge and it’s water proof! What more can a girl ask for

I used this for the first time on New Year's Day, and the results have been great. I'm happy with the fine tip, which allows me to create delicate and very subtle lines. The texture is good; one pass is enough to achieve a beautiful line. It's waterproof, which I really appreciate, and it's perfect for every season of the year.

The best

Completely dried out. Second liquid eyeliner product received from Target that’s been dried out.

Seems to dry out quickly but gets the job done

This is by far the best black eyeliner I’ve used. I’ve tried many other brands ranging from luxury to drug store and this wet n wild liner out performs them. First, having the brush tip instead of a felt tip always helps with a smoother and more even line. This product in particular has amazing staying power. If you have an issue with your eyeshadow creasing and/or liners smudging, you have to try this. The liner truly stays all day. I’ve even accidentally fallen asleep before removing my make up and the winged liner I did looked as if I first applied it. Removal is especially easy if you use a microfiber towel. Just lukewarm water on the towel removes it with ease.

It is really good my eyes tend to water a lot and it all stayed on and didn’t smudge or anything it was very light weight and comfortable and when applying it I only had to use one coat and it dried right away within seconds you do not need very much of it and it is very affordable.

I love this eyeliner. It creates the most crisp, perfect lines i have ever seen in a liner. Its a little drying since it is cryproof. But I love it so much. Its so pigmented. Bougie on a budget

It is really good my eyes tend to water a lot and it all stayed on and didn't smudge or anything it was very light weight and comfortable and when applying it I only had to use one coat and it dried right away within seconds you do not need very much of it and it is very affordable.

I love this eyeliner. It creates the most crisp perfect lines i have ever seen in a liner. Its a little drying since it is cryproof. But I love it so much. Its so pigmented. Bougie on a budget

I picked up the Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Skinny Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in a total pinch before an out-of-town work trip, and honestly… I was shooketh. I’ve been loyal to my KVD liner for years because nothing beats a crisp, sharp wing on my hooded lids… or so I thought. This little drugstore gem proved me wrong in the best way. The control is unreal. The skinny applicator gives you so much precision that getting a perfect base and flick feels effortless. The brush doesn’t fray, doesn’t skip, and lays down the blackest black line that stays saturated from start to finish. It’s incredibly easy to map out a wing, fill it in, and keep everything symmetrical… which we all know is half the battle. No wonky wings here! And the wear? Zero fading. Zero transfer onto my hooded lids. It stays exactly where you put it. Once it dries down, it’s locked in, but without that crunchy, stiff look some waterproof liners give. It survived a full day of work, travel, humidity… you name it. For the price, the performance is honestly insane. If you want a sharp wing, precise control, and true-black (matte) payoff that doesn’t budge, this liner delivers. I’m still shocked I found something that rivals my KVD… and possibly beats it.

I picked up the Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Skinny Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in a total pinch before an out-of-town work trip and honestly… I was shooketh. I've been loyal to my KVD liner for years because nothing beats a crisp sharp wing on my hooded lids… or so I thought. This little drugstore gem proved me wrong in the best way.The control is unreal. The skinny applicator gives you so much precision that getting a perfect base and flick feels effortless. The brush doesn't fray doesn't skip and lays down the blackest black line that stays saturated from start to finish. It's incredibly easy to map out a wing fill it in and keep everything symmetrical… which we all know is half the battle. No wonky wings here!And the wear? Zero fading. Zero transfer onto my hooded lids. It stays exactly where you put it. Once it dries down it's locked in but without that crunchy stiff look some waterproof liners give. It survived a full day of work travel humidity… you name it.For the price the performance is honestly insane. If you want a sharp wing precise control and true-black (matte) payoff that doesn't budge this liner delivers. I'm still shocked I found something that rivals my KVD… and possibly beats it.

The last two of these I’ve gotten have been basically dried out. Not sure what’s been going wrong since they used to be a staple in my rotation but… I’m basically wasting my money over and over hoping it goes back to how it was.